Friday, July 15, 2005

Functional Structures

Functional Structures: What are they?
Every organism has some kind of structure which defines it and makes its existence possible. Structure groups cells of various kinds together and not others, making a unique entity. Structure combines elements in ways that produce various compounds, but eliminates others. In some cases, the structures dominate, in others, the structures are all but invisible. In almost every case there are structures within structures, just as within the shape or structure of a leaf, there are structures which dictate photosynthesis, structures which boundary cells, structures which allow nutrients to come in to the leaf, etc. Thus, while we see only a leaf, were it not for the structures which allow it to function, there would be nothing. Every organism, then, not only has some kind of structure which defines it, but that structure itself is composed of other structures, giving it the possibility of functionality.

Systems Background
Probably one of the most freeing concepts to come from Natural Church Development is the truth that we are not responsible for producing fruit. This freedom allows the focus to be placed on areas which are within our ability to affect. By interacting with the eight characteristics of a healthy church we effectively, care for and intentionally enhance the environment so that, as God allows, fruit will come.

What I find interesting is the beauty of the connections. We see it everywhere in nature. The flowers are dependant upon the soil, the water, the air, the sunlight, and even the insects for pollination. Anyone of these factors can drastically affect the flower, and yet in harmony they produce great beauty. Scripture repeatedly uses the body as analogy for the church. I think that’s a wonderful picture into the intricacies of how even a small congregation is connected.
Our bodies truly are carefully and wonderfully made. Composed of cells and linked through a complex system of veins, arteries and nerves, over a structure of bone and cartilage, moved by muscles and independent thought, the body is marvelous. What is amazing is that even with all the complexity, it works wonderfully well. Yet, there are times when the body’s ability to function is impaired through accident, disease, age, etc. Its ability to function in a broader context is hampered by the impairment of function in a smaller context, e.g. sore throat, broken leg, toothache, etc. When this happens, even though only a small part of the body is primarily affected, the entire body’s ability to function is hampered or even destroyed (e.g. the world class skier who suffers an injury which makes it impossible to ever ski again).

In systems theory, all parts of an organism are perceived as connected and have the ability to affect the other parts. From the smallest cell to the defining boundaries, each part affects the whole. Interestingly, according to systems theory, although the strongest part gets recognized and valued, it is the weakest part which has the greatest power within the system. Natural Church Development recognized this truth with its focus upon the “minimum factor.” Regardless of the high levels of performance realized by any of the eight characteristics of a healthy church, the church’s true health depends upon the characteristic with the lowest level. Thus, while a church might have truly inspiring worship and appear healthy to the casual observer, it is the level of the lowest characteristic that dictates whether or not there is real health.

Structures which are Functional
Although “functional structures” is listed as one of the eight characteristics of a healthy church in its own right, it should also be observed that each of the other characteristics either has, or does not have, structures which are functional. Actually, it is the functionality of the structures within each characteristic which determine the health of that characteristic. Let’s look at some examples:

Empowering leadership is leadership which consciously seeks to empower others to their fullest potential. By giving away leadership to individuals equipped to accept responsibility and accountability, God’s work is multiplied. However, for this to happen there must exist structures which identify potential leaders as well as effective training method.

Gift oriented ministry is the heart of lay involvement and true edification of believers. For gift oriented ministry to become a reality there must exist structures which not only help identify gifts, but equip individuals to use their gifts and provide avenues for the use of those gifts.

“Holistic small groups” is considered one of the most important characteristics, yet the existence of these groups, and especially their health, depends totally upon structures which provide the right material, meeting parameters, and equipped leaders.

Inspiring worship seems to flow in the Spirit and brings the congregation into contact with God. What is not seen is the structures which include practice, music selection, and preparation, without which the flow becomes disjointed and distracting.

Loving relationships even require some structure. At the personal level relationships can become so static that without structures which motivate individuals to reach out to others, newcomers will feel excluded and unwanted. At the larger level, structure enables the church to effectively show the compassion which is part of its heart.

Need oriented evangelism is totally dependent upon structures which not only define the needs to be address but the methods of addressing those needs.

We would like to believe that at least passionate spirituality would be exempt from the need for structures. But here as well the need exists. The constant reminders of the prophets to the nation of Israel emphasize the fact that without structure people have a tendency to slip into spiritual apathy. In fact, it might be argued that one of the primary functions of the church itself is to provide the structure which motivates passionate spirituality. Yet, even within the church it doesn’t happen unless there are structures which point to the importance of consistent spiritual formation.

The characteristic of functional structures as used in NCD refers more specifically to the operational structures of organization and leadership, of resources and assets. In this are, at least, it is obvious that structure is imperative.

Identification Process
Since structures underlie each of the characteristics, how do we identify those structures, and whether or not they are truly functional?
After determining the characteristic with the “minimum factor” it is time to begin analyzing its underlying structures. In its most simplistic form, the steps to this analysis are:
1. Pray for guidance is selecting an analysis team
2. Call the team together and:
a. Pray together more than a simple prayer for God’s direction and guidance.
b. Appoint a recorder to record the information. This might seem obvious but this is VERY important.
c. Brainstorm together ONLY focusing upon those structures which currently exist to support that characteristic.
d. Work down the resultant list one by one discussing each point’s functionality. This is not the time to resource change, so stay focused. Place a triangle next to items which are not considered functional and a star next to items which are considered functional.
e. Send the team home with instructions to pray and meditate upon structures which will make this characteristic more functional.
f. At the next meeting begin again with prayer.
g. It is probable that this step may consume more than one meeting. Depending upon the size of the team it might speed things up to divide the team and assign each one certain points to discuss and come back with recommendations, which will also have to be discussed and modified before a consensus is reached.
3. Implementation of any recommendations MUST occur within the functional structures of the church as a whole and with the full knowledge and support of leadership.

Cautions
There are no formulistic solutions to church health. Two things which all solutions will have in common is prayer and a willingness to look objectively at what is and what might be.
Change, although inevitable, is studiously avoided by the church in general and can be threatening. The mere identification of a “minimum factor” will seem like heresy to some and a personal attack to others. Leaders would do well to understand the dynamics of influence and their own personal investment in relationships before challenging the security of entrenched pockets of power.

Monday, February 14, 2005

On May 11, 2004 I wrote that Leadership could be defined by two characteristics: Leaders participate and Leaders take responsibility. These two characteristics, are foundational to the nature of a leader . . . and both can be learned. Participation is the will to become involved. The will to choose to enter into the task at hand. Leaders will participate. They choose to contribute their skills and abilities to the mission, even to the defining of that mission and the strategic planning AND EXECUTION of those plans. Leaders Participate by choice. For some that choice may seem to be a natural expression of their personality, however, anyone can choose to participate and discipline themselves to enter into the fray. Whether it is the discussion in a classroom, participation in a local church project, or heading up a major project at work - those who participate are more likely to become involved in the leadership of that activity than those who sit back and wait.

Along the same lines is taking responsibility. Let's face it - most of the world is looking for someone else to take responsibility. Not the leader. She is willing to accept the responsibility for the success or failure of a project because she knows the gifts and abilities she brings to the table and is confident in her ability to succeed. The willingness to take responsibility characterizes those who are unwilling to simply allow and accept mediocrity. When her world slows to a stagnant point this leader will take responsibility for her own actions and move forward to a better place and a better solution.

Of course this conversation leads us to observe that there ARE gifts and abilities which are also part of the Leaders quiver. This will be the subject of another post.

Monday, January 10, 2005

So, I'm talking with a friend today who was basically lied to by his boss about why a certain component of his salary package could not be offered, only to find out it had been offered to the previous person to hold the same position. He was understandably upset and thwarted in his desire to confront the "boss" because the boss was out of town for a couple of days.

I asked him what he wanted as a result of the confrontation. He said that he wanted the boss to promise to be truthful in the future. I shared with him the story of the scorpion and the frog and suggested that a promise from a scorpion is worth exactly nothing if it runs contrary to the nature of the scorpion. So, now what do you want from the confrontation; an apology? an increase in your salary package? what.

The bottom line is that confrontation without a clear purpose is usually a matter of salving the ego as much as it is about justice. And if it is about ego, then one has to examine one's motive for the work. If your motive is because this is your calling - then confrontation only has value as it secures justice, not just to make you feel like you stood up for yourself. This is not a philosophy for the individual with insecurity issues. Can you rise above your own ego to pursue the best path for the organization? Yet, even in calling there is a line where one cannot turn away from situations which require a stand to be made. How one makes that stand, however, IS within your power and many do not take into account the power of their words, nor the long term effect of a hastily spoken word. Judgement as to another's motives is always risky at best and often puts you in the position of the pot calling the kettle black. Thank you very much Mr. Pot. You are welcome, Mr. Kettle.

However, if your motive for being at the organization is NOT a calling but merely a step toward a personal goal, confrontation may be of greater necessity, yet again, the choice of the wording is crucial to a satisfactory resolution. It seems that some people have an uncanny knack of selecting words which cause others to respond with anger and a desire to hurt back.

Coming back to the issue cited at the beginning of this post. Integrity in leadership cannot be overstated. Say what you mean, mean what you say, and let what you say be the truth.

Sunday, December 26, 2004

Christmas 2004 is almost over, I guess, technically, it is over as it is 12:20 AM on the 26th. The issues of leadership have continued to press themselves upon my awareness over the last few months. Leadership and management, while having some functions in common are not the same thing. What I see more often than not is individuals with some skill at management, to varying degrees, proving to be somewhat competent, and therefore, being perceived as being a leader. Leadership is one of the functions of management, however, it is leadership within the confines of the organizational blueprint - the smooth functioning of and incremental improvement of the organization along the path designated. This pseudoleadership is important to the organization, but must not be confused with true leadership. True leaders may have some competency in management, if the organization is lucky, but their primary function IS the future and the strategic plan. The plain truth is that anyone who can exhibit any aspect of leadership and the willingness to take on responsibility will eventually move up in thier company, or move to another where they can move up. This is because leadership is in short supply - everywhere.

Tuesday, May 11, 2004

Lately I have been thinking about how personality contributes to leadership. I'm not speaking of personality types such as sanguine, melancholoy, etc. Instead, I'm wondering if there might not be a specific personality type for leaders (and, therefore, one for followers, and one more for those who are basically clueless).

If there is a personality type: "Leader" then, is it the type which simply is (e.g. sanguine, melancholoy, etc) or is it one which can be acquired. How does one acquire it. Obviously training in leadership principles can make one more aware of what the personality type looks like, however, I am coming to the conclusion that actually acquiring the personality of Leader hinges on two factors:

1. Choose to participate. Leaders participate in every process of which they are a part. You could sooner keep a duck from quacking than to keep a leader from participating. It is part of who they are. I remember when I choose to start participating. I was in a college class and I knew if I didn't participate, I would fall asleep. I became active not only in that class but in every class and that choice has become my nature.

2. Choose to take responsibility. Leaders initiate taking responsibility. They take responsibility for group functions. They take responsibility and process it in a way which benefits the group as a whole.

I haven't refined these concepts yet but I believe that all the other data about leadership may hinge more on these two factors than be the answers themselves.

Monday, April 26, 2004

John Kotter in Leading Change cites eight reasons why transitions (planned change) in firms fail: 1) They allow too much complacency, 2) They fail to create a sufficiently powerful guiding coalition, 3) They underestimate the power of VISION, 4) They undercommunicate the VISION by a facgtor of 10 (or 100 or even 1,000), 5) They permit pbstacles to block the new vision, 6) They fail to create short-term wins, 7) They declare victory too soon (and quit trying), and, finally, 8) They neglect to anchor changes in the corporate culture.

I wonder which of these points you could point to as the main reason the last change plan you were involved with failed. Obviously planned change may require more from leadership than a simple mandate if it is to become a long-term reality. It is interesting that VISION is mentioned in two of the point cited by Kotter: underestimating the power of VISION and undercommunicating the VISION. I suppose this makes sense when one considers that it was VISION which decided the course of the change to begin with.

Monday, April 12, 2004

It amazes me what passes for leadership . . . and the significant lack thereof. Probably the best book I have read recently discussing one aspect of leadership has been Leading Change by Kotter. The concepts presented in this book are universal and if considered will assist any leader in facilitating change within the organization. Key, of course to change is the create the sense of urgency that change, although possibly not desirable, is certainly unavoidable - what can be avoided, with some effort, is negative change. For example, the economic situation may mean that a business will definitely suffer financial reversals UNLESS some change occurs. With the inevitability of change coming, all that remains is to determine which changes can bring forth positive returns instead of negative, for the largest number of stakeholders. This, of course, recognizes that not all stakeholders will benefit or even survive the change, at least in their current incarnation.

Friday, September 26, 2003

Does leadership require a team? Does the team paradigm enhance the function of leadership? I believe so. All the current leadership agrees, yet . . . what do you do when you find yourself in a context which gives verbal assent to the concept while practicing a practical autocracy? Depending upon your position within the organization . . . and the approachableness of the autocrat, the answer may be "live with it." This is hardly an answer, however, for the individual who seeks the fulfillment which could be part of such a team. In this case, it will be up to the individual to evaluate his own calling, position of service and prayerfully consider what God wants, both for the organization (which may mean sticking with the program) and the individual.

Thursday, September 04, 2003

Issues on Strategic Planning. It is amazing to me that this concept is so misunderstood. Planning which is strategic is simply planning which is designed to accomplish a set of goals. Thus, Strategic Planning is completely mis-named if one does not have a set of goals or outcomes. If one has a goal, in the church world for instance, of developing a better, more informed, awareness of the Word of God among the congregation, then the strategic plan would lead to that reality. Obviously, time-lines and resources are important considerations, as is the very real consideration of just how many goals an institution can pursue at any one time (and which of these have the highest priority). These factors make strategic planning complex, but even more complex than the plan, in my opinion is the process used to define the goals, thier priority, and the time line for accomplishing those goals. And this hinges upon the mission of the institution. Another factor is the "brand" image of the institution both internally and externally. OK, I guess I can see how strategic planning can be mis-understood. After all if you undertake to do "strategic planning" when you have not addressed the mission, the brand and the goals, what can you expect, except confusion.

Sunday, July 20, 2003

Life abhors a vacumn. A vacancy demands that something fill that space. This is especially true in Leadership. When there is no leadership in an organization, or the leadership is inadequate, one of two things will happen. Those who recognize the need will either move toward filling need, or, if that is not possible or the structure cannot be solved without the additional clout of position, these people will leave the situation/organization.

Leaders are influencers. In the best sense they use their influence to empower those around them in the fulfillment of the goals. In the worse sense, they manipulate those around them to make themselves look good regardless of anyone else.

Friday, July 11, 2003

7/11/03 One of the best books I have recently read on the subject of leadership is The Next Generation Leader by Andy Stanley. Although the book is not very long, it is well written and challenges past the basics. I recommend this book and will be posting reflections from my reading in upcoming blogs.
7/11/03 I don't know why but I couldn't sleep this morning and it seemed like a good idea just to go ahead and get up and make an entry here. I have been thinking a lot about the mechanics of leadership and realize that, even though those mechanics can be learned, the heart of a leader is developed much earlier, while growing up. There are certain principles of life which I believe to be foundational enough that I have attempted to teach them to my children from their earliest days. They are: 1. All of life can be reduced to relationships, 2. Everything rises and falls on leadership, 3. Excellence in all things, 4. It is not what happens to you but how you respond, and 5. Perseverance - don't quit. These principles are then build on the Shema which says: The Lord God is ONE, love the Lord with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your strength. I can't overemphasize the importance of these principles when practiced in conjunction with the guiding force of the Shema. Teach them to your children, talk about them at the table over a meal, meditate upon them in the situations of your life.

Wednesday, July 09, 2003

7/9/03 Communication is a key component to effective leadership. In fact, you could say that without strong communication skills leadership, at least over the long haul, is impossible. What are the basic pieces of the skill set needed for effective communication? Just remember your PEAS. P=precision. A leader's communicatin must be clear, without ambiguity. E=enunciate, as in pronounce the words correctly. It is VERY annoying to hear people in leadership mispronounce words. A=articulate, as in make sure you speak distinctly enough to be clearly heard by everyone in the audience (whether that audience is one person or a hundred). Mumbled, indistinct speech is a big off-putter. S=simple. Keep your focus on the subject at hand.

Monday, June 23, 2003

6/23/03 There are some who might contest the truth expressed in the title of this blog, i.e. that everything rises and falls on leadership. They might contest that leadership is but one of the components of success and that other factors contribute to the rise or fall of any endeavor. And there is some truth in such an observation. However, all other factors can be overcome/enhanced through good leadership, or be allowed to scapegoat poor leadership. That is the core of much of what we see happen around us: Leaders who whine about inadequate resources, inept followers, and the unfairness of their circumstances. Unfortunately, true leadership is rare. Leaders whose passion and willingness to "stand in the gap" are the great need of our nation, our communities and our churches. Although this theme "Everything rises and falls on leadership" first came to my attention through the work of John Maxwell, I have tested its validity in a myriad of situations and can definitely attest that even when it seems as if there are reasonable excuses for failure, leadership is the culprit, just as consistent success is the evidence of good leadership.

Are you succeeding or failing? Have you taken leadership of your own life, or are you waiting on something to happen so that you do not have to expend the effort?
6/23/03 I am beginning this Blog as a result of an experience I had while attending ALIVE 03 in Canton, OH. During that time I sensed that I needed to be sharing some of the information which I have accumulated on the subject of leadership. I will be posting critical reviews of various books, articles, and chapters, as well as personal observations about leadership.